Now Reading...
The Soapbox

S is for SAHM

The whole “Stay-at-Home Mom” vs. “Working Mom” debate is back in the forefront of the media. It’s a stupid non-issue, but thanks to an election cycle full of such nonsense intended to distract us from “real” issues (for example–poverty, the economy, Afghanistan), it’s the “at this moment” issue in the race.

Like Bruno Gianelli so wisely proclaimed on The West Wing: “The biggest nonsense issue in the campaign will belong to the women. Does Abbey Bartlet love her children? Next week, Grandpa: friend or foe?”

Hilary Rosen’s comments that ignited this latest skirmish were offensive, snide, and condescending. She showed considerable lack of judgment in her word choice. But her overall point had nothing to do with putting down women who stayed home with their children. Of course, SAHMs work their butts off. I know. I am one. (Well, I suppose technically I am a part-time WAHM—work-at-home mom—but I am on mommy duty 24/7, so I consider myself a SAHM before I’m a WAHM. But I digress…) Only the most ignorant of either gender would deny that.

What has gotten under my skin lately is that, in trying to explain and defend Rosen’s comments, the left keeps trotting out the phrase, “the luxury to stay at home”. Luxury? Really?

I have tremendous respect and admiration for any woman who has to raise a family and work a full-time job. I honestly don’t know how these women do it. I only work a few hours a month, and I find it hard to keep up with both my family and my self-employment obligations. The irony of all these pundits and commentators purporting to speak on behalf of those women who don’t have “the luxury” of staying at home with their children is that each of them DOES. Does anyone really believe that Hilary Rosen and those of her stature would face debilitating poverty and become homeless if they didn’t work? They have a choice, and theirs is to work. The women they are supposed to be speaking for do not have that same choice.

To color the choice of staying at home as a “luxury” is disingenuous at best, and condescending at worst. One could just as easily say it’s a “luxury” to be able to work in a high-paying, rewarding job outside the home. For some of us, staying at home is the only option because the cost of decent, reliable day care is out of reach.

I’ve talked about my own journey from career to motherhood. Being a SAHM wasn’t my choice. Our plan was for me to continue my career, while my husband became a SAHD and worked on his education. Thanks to the Iraq War, that plan was shot to hell when my husband was recalled to active duty and sent overseas.

I could have found day care for my daughter. It would have meant someone else raising her for 14 hours a day, 5 days a week. But I could have done that, and I could have kept my career on-track. We would not have had to worry about making the mortgage payment. We could have made all the household improvements that, ten years later, we’re still trying to save enough to make. We wouldn’t have to beg, borrow, and steal to send our kids to a decent school; when someone needs new shoes, we wouldn’t have to make them wait until there was a good enough sale or I had a coupon; we would be able to buy the healthier organic/natural selections at the market without a moment’s consideration.

But while being a SAHM wasn’t my first choice, it was the only choice for my family. It’s not a “luxury”. Premium cable channels, a hybrid SUV, an iPad, a full-time nanny—those are luxuries. Staying home with my children, even though it can be frustrating and demoralizing at times, is a privilege. I haven’t always felt that way. I truly resented being forced into a position where I felt I had no choice. But my perspective has changed as my circumstances have, and it’s a privilege that my family and I suffer and sacrifice for. It’s a choice that many women work hard to make feasible.

Instead of focusing on the choices that women make for their families, how about we focus on the underlying issues that limit the options? How about we women—left, center, right—shake hands, respect one another, and then get down to work to make this country a place where someone doesn’t have to choose between buying their kid new shoes or paying for gas to get to work? Let’s make this a place where women who sacrifice to stay at home are regarded with as much respect as women who are their family’s breadwinner.

And let’s stop knocking each other down. Lord knows, there are enough men in this world to do that to us.

For a more detailed opinion piece, check out Slate’s The Faux Mommy Wars.

About Cate Tayler

Mom, Wife, Writer, Catholic, Thinker, Reader, Amateur Gourmand, 'Phins Fan, Superwoman--not always in that order. Fueled by passion and too much caffeine. Lost my cape--it's buried somewhere under that mountain of laundry. Once I find it, look out world!


One thought on “S is for SAHM

  1. This is wonderfully well written and gave me a different perspective, thank you. I was a SAHM for a number of years. If we could have had more than one child I probably still would be. I know it was the right choice. Your final two sentences sum it up nicely. Brava!

    Posted by jyllianm | April 27, 2012, 07:25

Talk to us!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Blogs We Follow

Rev. Dr. Evan M. Dolive

Follower of Christ, Father, Husband, Author, Blogger, All Around Nice Guy

Interrupting the Silence

An Episcopal Priest's Sermons, Prayers, and Reflections on Life, Becoming Human, and Discovering Our Divinity

MK is Stacked

The epitome of librarian boob puns.

Life Through the Big Screen

A podcast where I invite guests from all walks of life to discuss their favorite movies, and we use that film as a starting point to talk about deeper issues such as faith, politics, and social issues.

A Common Sea

"I feel we are all islands floating in a common sea"--Anne Morrow Lindbergh

Pie Eyed

Living the Pie Life

Just Me With . . .

a blog without a niche

The Cake Eccentric's Blog

Cake Artist Serving New York's Capital Region 855.518.CAKE


Resources for Writers

What Matters Most

A Mother's Devotional


Independent views from someone who offers some historical context

Gastronomical Three

"First we eat, then we do everything else." --M.F.K. Fisher

Write, Read, Watch

Bringing the frights you deserve.

The Fearless Cooking Club

It's never too late to start

%d bloggers like this: